Justice in a time of madness

A review of City of Shadows by Ariana Franklin

Berlin in the 1920s was a desperate city, its collection of decadant cabarets a veneer for a population struggling to survive after the horrors of the first World War.  As such, it's an apt home for Esther Solomonova, a Jewish Russian emigree who bears the literal and emotional scars of the tumultuous Russian revolution.  She has only begun to put her past behind her when her employer, the flamboyant club owner 'Prince' Nick, discovers a woman in a local insane hospital that he believes is Grand Duchess Anastasia, the sole surviving member of the Russian royal family. 

Nick hopes to cash in on the royal wealth, and Esther is given the task of making Anastasia--or Anna Anderson, as she is known to the skeptical--into believable royalty.  But soon people associated with the would-be princess begin to turn up murdered.  Esther has her suspicions that the identity of the murderer can be found in Anna's murky past, but it is only when Inspector Siegfried Schmidt takes on the case that the truth begins to be revealed.  But in a city that is rapidly coming under the domination of the rising Nazi party, Schmidt and Esther struggle for justice in a new Germany that has little respect for the law. 

Ariana Franklin's suspense novel City of Shadows masterfully blends the fictional and the historical into an atmospheric mystery with a climactic finish.  Although Esther and Schmidt are fictional, there was a real Anna Anderson whose story Franklin follows fairly closely.  Perhaps the best aspect to Franklin's novel, however, is the depiction of Berlin, which comes to life as fully as the human characters to create a compelling mystery in a time and place gone terribly wrong.

Comments

We read this one for my mystery book group and had mixed reactions. A few of us really liked it for the very reasons you mention. Some thought it wasn't enough of a mystery or that the mystery took too long to get started - both fair points but still a good book for discussion.

When I wrote this review, I hesitated before I put it under the mystery heading. While reading City of Shadows, I felt like some aspects of the book reminded me of Patricia Highsmith's writing (in the development of the characters) and Benjamin Black's noir novel Christine Falls, in the atmospheric depiction of its Dublin setting. Both of those books could fall into that gray area between fiction and mystery, and I believe the same could be said of City of Shadows.

For all book groups out there: we've ordered this as part of our Book Discussion Kit Collection. If you're looking for a pick for 2008, we've got 8 copies and a discussion guide that can be shipped out. Here's the link to the Book Discussion Kit Collection:
http://www.madisonpubliclibrary.org/bookgroups/bookclubkits.html

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.